SYDNEY - Australia plans to
use an armed detention ship to house illegal Asian fishermen caught off its
remote northern coast, sparking criticism that keeping people in a floating
prison would breach human rights obligations. Australian Prime Minister John
Howard, who has enforced a tough border protection policy, said the detention
ship was appropriate as Australia faced a stream of illegal fishermen.
"The need for it is obvious. You can have a situation where you could have a
surge of illegal fishermen and women and a holding capacity of that kind is very
sensible," he said.
"This is a particular need in a special situation," Howard told reporters
Thursday.
Civil libertarians, the Labor opposition and the Australian Greens party all
condemned the prison ship plan as uncivilised, drawing comparisons with British
convicts sent from overflowing prison hulks to Australia more than 200 years
ago.
"A couple of centuries ago people were condemned to hulks for stealing
bread," said Pauline Spencer, from Victoria state's Federation of Community
Legal Centres.
"Now we're looking at people being condemned to these hulks for stealing
fish...," she told reporters.
Australia, which automatically detains asylum seekers arriving by boat on
remote islands or outback centres, has intercepted 234 foreign fishing vessels
this year, more than double the number caught last year.
Most of those detained are Indonesian fishermen seeking lucrative shark fins.
They are fined and sent back to their villages but their ships are burned.
Australian Customs has advertised for tenders to lease a vessel that will act
as an offshore detention ship capable of holding 30 detainees and be fitted with
deck-mounted machine guns, a spokesman for Fisheries Minister Eric Abetz said.
The ship would be used to secure illegal arrivals at sea for two to three
days, allowing navy vessels to keep patrolling
instead of immediately returning to port with detainees.
"We need a vessel that will be able to hold illegal fishers out at sea so we
can round up even more of the boats," Abetz told reporters.
Australia already operates a detention-supply ship, the Oceanic Viking, in
its cold southern waters. It is used to hold illegal fishermen caught with
valuable Patagonian Toothfish.
In March, the Oceanic Viking was deployed for two weeks off northern
Australia where it held two groups of 40 Asian fishermen, ferrying them to the
tropical port of Darwin.
Its success prompted the decision to deploy a detention ship in northern
waters.
Australia will spend A$10 million ($7.6 million) a year leasing the new ship,
which could be operating by early 2007.
"This policy harks back to Australia's penal history, when we should be at
the forefront of compassionate and human solutions to border issues," Greens
Senator Kerry Nettle said in a statement.
The Australian Council for Civil Liberties said the plan should be ditched.
It was concerned about human rights abuses because the detention ship would keep
detainees far from public scrutiny.
In May, Australia said it would spend A$500 million toughening security of
its remote northern border with more surveillance flights and sea patrols.
Nearly A$400 million will be spent combating illegal fishing.